Difference between revisions of "Help:Categories"

From Camera-wiki.org
Jump to: navigation, search
(removed a part that was advising duplicate categories)
(Basics: making some corrections)
 
(34 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
In Camerapedia, the pages are indexed by wiki categories. To know more about what Wiki categories are and how to use them, you can follow [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Categorization this external link] to the corresponding help page of Wikipedia.
+
Camera-wiki.org uses Mediawiki '''categories''', in order to help readers find related information. Categories are listed at the foot of each page. As examples, you will see "Category:Editing guidelines" at the foot of ''this'' page, and "Category:Japanese 35mm rangefinder" at the bottom of the [[Konica Auto S3]] article.
  
Camerapedia is trying to setup its own policy of categorization. Before indexing your page, you can browse through the categories, all the way down from the [[:Category:Root category|Root category]].
+
To discover more about what Mediawiki categories are and how to use them, you can try clicking on any category links you find in Camera-wiki.org and see what happens, or you can explore the "Further reading" at the foot of this page.
 +
 
 +
==Basics==
 +
 
 +
The [[Hasselblad 500 C/M]] is in [[:Category:6x6 SLR]], [[:Category:Sweden]] and [[:Category:Hasselblad]] (and perhaps in other categories too). Unless you have taken the option (in "Preferences") to change the "skin" (appearance) of Camera-Wiki.org, links to these will appear at the foot of the article. (With a different skin, they may instead appear at the top.) Clicking any of these links will take you to a list of other articles in the category.
 +
 
 +
(You may think that you should somehow be able to select ''both'' [[:Category:6x6 SLR]] ''and'' [[:Category:Sweden]] and thereby get a list of Swedish 6×6 SLRs. However, the Mediawiki software unfortunately does not allow for this.<ref>More strictly speaking, it does allow for this. However, it does so with bugs, and therefore this is not implemented here.</ref>)
 +
 
 +
Camera-wiki.org has its own policies of categorization. Before adding categories to a page (let alone creating a new category), please familiarize yourself with the kinds of categories other articles use. You can do this in any of various ways. You can examine the categories to which a similar subject (camera, etc.) belongs; or you can browse a complete [[Special:Categories | alphabetical list]] of categories (jump around in the alphabet via the search box).
 +
 
 +
Categories that only include one or two members are not particularly helpful; they should be avoided. You can open a [http://camera-wiki.org/index.php?title=Special:MostLinkedCategories&limit=700 list of Camera-wiki.org's most-used categories], then use your browser's "Find" function to discover what relevant categories are already being used. When you add a category to a page, the capitalization, spelling, etc. must exactly match the existing category.
 +
 
 +
Categories are nested; so beginning at [[:Category:Contents]] (the most basic category of all), you can go via [[:Category:Articles]] to explore outwards through branches of the category tree: From [[:Category:Countries]] on to [[:Category:Germany]], to [[:Category:German cameras]], to [[:Category:German 6x6]], and to [[:Category:German 6x6 pseudo TLR]]; and finally to examples such as [[Pucky]].
 +
 
 +
==Categories for articles on cameras==
 +
 
 +
Categories aren't only used for articles on cameras, but because the overwhelming majority of articles in Camera-wiki.org are on cameras we'll look at the categorization of such articles.
  
 
A page about a specific camera model should have the following categories:
 
A page about a specific camera model should have the following categories:
 
* one or more categories for the type of camera
 
* one or more categories for the type of camera
* a category for the lens mount if relevant enough
 
 
* a category for the country of origin
 
* a category for the country of origin
* a category for the camera maker if relevant enough
 
 
* one or two categories for the alphabetical index
 
* one or two categories for the alphabetical index
  
For example, the Nikon D70 will likely have the following categories:
+
The "country of origin" is normally that where the design was done: a camera planned in Japan and assembled in Malaysia is thus treated as having originated in Japan.
* Category: Digital SLR
+
 
* Category: Nikon F mount
+
Japan and Germany are special cases: A category "Japan" would include hundreds of pages—too many to be useful. Instead "Japanese" or "German" are used as qualifiers for other camera categories.  While the Swedish [[Hasselblad 500 C/M]] is in included in the categories
* Category: Japan
+
* [[:Category:6x6 SLR]]
* Category: Nikon
+
* [[:Category:Sweden]]
* Category: N
+
 
* Category: D|D70, this trick is to list the Nikon D70 under the D page at the right place, not at the bottom
+
In contrast, the [[Minolta SR-1]] is included in
 +
* [[:Category:Japanese 35mm SLR]]
 +
 
 +
And the Voigtländer [[Vitessa]] is in
 +
* [[:Category:German 35mm rangefinder folding]]
 +
 
 +
 
 +
A page about a specific camera model may also be in the following categories:
 +
* a category for the lens mount (if applicable and if such a category seems helpful<ref>For widely known cameras with interchangeable lenses, it usually is helpful. By contrast, the Meopta [[Opema]] takes interchangeable screwmount (M38)<!-- Yes, M38; not M39 --> lenses. It is not known to share these with any other camera; thus it is not helpful to create a category for its lens mount.</ref>)
 +
* a category for the camera maker (if such a category seems helpful<ref>Obviously Canon, Nikon, Zeiss, etc are helpful. But since the [[Ako folders]] are the only cameras known to have been sold (and perhaps made) by [[Ako Shōkai]], there's little point in creating an "Ako" category.</ref>)
 +
 
 +
For example, the [[Sony Alpha DSLR-A100]] would be in the following categories (as well as perhaps in others):
 +
*[[:Category:Japanese digital SLR]]
 +
*[[:Category:Sony]] alphabetized under Alpha DSLR-A100<ref>Adding a pipe character to the markup, <nowiki>[[:Category: Sony|Alpha DSLR-A100]]</nowiki> lists the entry in the Sony index under the A's for "Alpha", not the S's for "Sony Alpha")</ref>
 +
*[[:Category:Minolta AF mount]]
 +
*[[:Category:A]] (alphabetical listings)
 +
*[[:Category:S]] (ditto)
 +
 
 +
and the [[Vitessa]] folder in the following:
 +
* [[:Category:German 35mm rangefinder folding]]
 +
* [[:Category:Barn door]]
 +
* [[:Category:Voigtländer]]
 +
* [[:Category:V]]
 +
 
 +
These articles could imaginably be put in various other categories; for example, the former could be in "SLR cameras". However, the general rule is to '''put a page only in the most specific category''', and not to put it in any of the parents of this category. So the Sony Alpha DSLR-A100 goes into the category "Japanese digital SLR" and ''not'' also into any of categories "Japanese SLR", "Japanese digital", "Digital SLR", "Digital", or "Japanese cameras".
 +
 
 +
(This general rule is sometimes broken; for example, cameras from the former East Germany are considered by most people as being German as well, and so are listed both in the "Category:East Germany" and in the corresponding "German" category.)
 +
 
 +
==Creating new categories==
 +
 
 +
Please think very carefully before creating a new category. If you create one and you or others later decide that it is unsuitable or better renamed, a lot of work will be required.
 +
 
 +
This is in part because categories cannot be renamed. To achieve the more-or-less equivalent of renaming a category, it's necessary to (i) create the new category, (ii) change the link to the category within every article in the old category, and (iii) delete the old category. The second of these stages can be exhausting.
 +
 
 +
If in any doubt, propose the new category in one or more relevant talk pages and wait to see what reaction there is to your proposal. Be circumspect in creating even one new category.
 +
 
 +
==Markup==
 +
 
 +
Add any category to, or very close to, the foot of the article.
 +
 
 +
Adding <nowiki>[[Category:Nikon]]</nowiki> to a page adds that page to the Nikon category.
 +
 
 +
By contrast, adding <nowiki>[[:Category:Nikon]]</nowiki> &mdash; note the extra colon at the start &mdash; to a page does not add that page to the Nikon category but instead provides a regular inline link to the Nikon category. This is something that's seldom done, other than in order to discuss categories themselves (as within this very page).
 +
 
 +
Adding <nowiki>[[Category:Nikon]]</nowiki> to a page on the Nikon F2 adds that article to the category's list with "Nikon F2" alphabetized under N. This is not what we want. Adding <nowiki>[[Category:Nikon|F2]]</nowiki> &mdash; note the pipe character "|" &mdash; adds the article to the list alphabetized by "F2": better.
 +
 
 +
Adding <nowiki>[[Category:Nikon]]</nowiki> to a the main page discussing Nikon (the company) adds that article to the list alphabetized under "N". Again, not so good. Adding <nowiki>[[Category:Nikon|*]]</nowiki> displays the article to the top of the list: better.
 +
 
 +
==In the absence of a conclusion==
 +
 
 +
There are still many points to be discussed about categorization. Please think for yourself and post new ideas in [[Help talk:Categories|the discussion page]]. Although you're asked above to be wary of creating new categories, you can be as bold as you like in suggesting changes to categories.
 +
 
 +
==Notes==
 +
 
 +
<references />
 +
 
 +
==Further reading==
  
The same page could be put in various other categories, for example in "SLR cameras". However, the general rule is not to put a page in the most specific category, and not to put it in a category and the mother category at the same time. So the D70 goes to "Category:Digital SLR" and is not listed under "Category:SLR". Currently this general rule is broken in some cases, for example:
+
*[http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Help:Category Category help] (at Wikimedia)
* cameras from the former East Germany are considered by most people as being German as well, so are listed in both
+
*[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Categorization Categorization] (at Wikipedia)
 +
*[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Categorization_FAQ Categorization FAQ] (at Wikipedia)
  
There are still many points to be discussed about this scheme. I invite you to experiment and post ideas in the discussion page.
+
[[Category:Editing guidelines]]

Latest revision as of 07:13, 5 February 2012

Camera-wiki.org uses Mediawiki categories, in order to help readers find related information. Categories are listed at the foot of each page. As examples, you will see "Category:Editing guidelines" at the foot of this page, and "Category:Japanese 35mm rangefinder" at the bottom of the Konica Auto S3 article.

To discover more about what Mediawiki categories are and how to use them, you can try clicking on any category links you find in Camera-wiki.org and see what happens, or you can explore the "Further reading" at the foot of this page.

Basics

The Hasselblad 500 C/M is in Category:6x6 SLR, Category:Sweden and Category:Hasselblad (and perhaps in other categories too). Unless you have taken the option (in "Preferences") to change the "skin" (appearance) of Camera-Wiki.org, links to these will appear at the foot of the article. (With a different skin, they may instead appear at the top.) Clicking any of these links will take you to a list of other articles in the category.

(You may think that you should somehow be able to select both Category:6x6 SLR and Category:Sweden and thereby get a list of Swedish 6×6 SLRs. However, the Mediawiki software unfortunately does not allow for this.[1])

Camera-wiki.org has its own policies of categorization. Before adding categories to a page (let alone creating a new category), please familiarize yourself with the kinds of categories other articles use. You can do this in any of various ways. You can examine the categories to which a similar subject (camera, etc.) belongs; or you can browse a complete alphabetical list of categories (jump around in the alphabet via the search box).

Categories that only include one or two members are not particularly helpful; they should be avoided. You can open a list of Camera-wiki.org's most-used categories, then use your browser's "Find" function to discover what relevant categories are already being used. When you add a category to a page, the capitalization, spelling, etc. must exactly match the existing category.

Categories are nested; so beginning at Category:Contents (the most basic category of all), you can go via Category:Articles to explore outwards through branches of the category tree: From Category:Countries on to Category:Germany, to Category:German cameras, to Category:German 6x6, and to Category:German 6x6 pseudo TLR; and finally to examples such as Pucky.

Categories for articles on cameras

Categories aren't only used for articles on cameras, but because the overwhelming majority of articles in Camera-wiki.org are on cameras we'll look at the categorization of such articles.

A page about a specific camera model should have the following categories:

  • one or more categories for the type of camera
  • a category for the country of origin
  • one or two categories for the alphabetical index

The "country of origin" is normally that where the design was done: a camera planned in Japan and assembled in Malaysia is thus treated as having originated in Japan.

Japan and Germany are special cases: A category "Japan" would include hundreds of pages—too many to be useful. Instead "Japanese" or "German" are used as qualifiers for other camera categories. While the Swedish Hasselblad 500 C/M is in included in the categories

In contrast, the Minolta SR-1 is included in

And the Voigtländer Vitessa is in


A page about a specific camera model may also be in the following categories:

  • a category for the lens mount (if applicable and if such a category seems helpful[2])
  • a category for the camera maker (if such a category seems helpful[3])

For example, the Sony Alpha DSLR-A100 would be in the following categories (as well as perhaps in others):

and the Vitessa folder in the following:

These articles could imaginably be put in various other categories; for example, the former could be in "SLR cameras". However, the general rule is to put a page only in the most specific category, and not to put it in any of the parents of this category. So the Sony Alpha DSLR-A100 goes into the category "Japanese digital SLR" and not also into any of categories "Japanese SLR", "Japanese digital", "Digital SLR", "Digital", or "Japanese cameras".

(This general rule is sometimes broken; for example, cameras from the former East Germany are considered by most people as being German as well, and so are listed both in the "Category:East Germany" and in the corresponding "German" category.)

Creating new categories

Please think very carefully before creating a new category. If you create one and you or others later decide that it is unsuitable or better renamed, a lot of work will be required.

This is in part because categories cannot be renamed. To achieve the more-or-less equivalent of renaming a category, it's necessary to (i) create the new category, (ii) change the link to the category within every article in the old category, and (iii) delete the old category. The second of these stages can be exhausting.

If in any doubt, propose the new category in one or more relevant talk pages and wait to see what reaction there is to your proposal. Be circumspect in creating even one new category.

Markup

Add any category to, or very close to, the foot of the article.

Adding [[Category:Nikon]] to a page adds that page to the Nikon category.

By contrast, adding [[:Category:Nikon]] — note the extra colon at the start — to a page does not add that page to the Nikon category but instead provides a regular inline link to the Nikon category. This is something that's seldom done, other than in order to discuss categories themselves (as within this very page).

Adding [[Category:Nikon]] to a page on the Nikon F2 adds that article to the category's list with "Nikon F2" alphabetized under N. This is not what we want. Adding [[Category:Nikon|F2]] — note the pipe character "|" — adds the article to the list alphabetized by "F2": better.

Adding [[Category:Nikon]] to a the main page discussing Nikon (the company) adds that article to the list alphabetized under "N". Again, not so good. Adding [[Category:Nikon|*]] displays the article to the top of the list: better.

In the absence of a conclusion

There are still many points to be discussed about categorization. Please think for yourself and post new ideas in the discussion page. Although you're asked above to be wary of creating new categories, you can be as bold as you like in suggesting changes to categories.

Notes

  1. More strictly speaking, it does allow for this. However, it does so with bugs, and therefore this is not implemented here.
  2. For widely known cameras with interchangeable lenses, it usually is helpful. By contrast, the Meopta Opema takes interchangeable screwmount (M38) lenses. It is not known to share these with any other camera; thus it is not helpful to create a category for its lens mount.
  3. Obviously Canon, Nikon, Zeiss, etc are helpful. But since the Ako folders are the only cameras known to have been sold (and perhaps made) by Ako Shōkai, there's little point in creating an "Ako" category.
  4. Adding a pipe character to the markup, [[:Category: Sony|Alpha DSLR-A100]] lists the entry in the Sony index under the A's for "Alpha", not the S's for "Sony Alpha")

Further reading